Search This Blog

Showing posts with label a. Show all posts
Showing posts with label a. Show all posts

Wednesday, 3 September 2014

Agents, their duties and secret commissions

When we hear the word agent our first thoughts are of real estate agents. However, an agent in a legal sense actually covers an expansive range of relationships between a person or company (an agent) and another (referred to as a principal) who has undertaken to serve their best interests.


Whether or not a relationship of agency exists is a question which the courts approach objectively[1]. There are many examples of established agency relationships. Here are a few;

·         Real estate agent and client
·         Solicitor and client
·         Employee and employer
·         Joint venturers (to each other)
·         The director of a company (to the company)


Scope of an agent’s duties
While the scope of the duties owed by an agent to their principal will vary depending on the type of agency, a fundamental duty of an agent is not to use their position to make a gain for themselves without the knowledge and assent of the principal[2].
An agent should consider if there is any personal interest in the matter which might conflict with the duty owed to the intended principal and, if so, he or she should decline to act as agent without the fully informed consent of the principal[3].


Profit from position and secret commissions
If an agent is aware of any circumstances which might influence their client’s decision to enter into a negotiation, and fails to disclose that information to their client, the commission may be forfeited[4].
If the agent does receive profit as a result of that non-disclosure, these profits are recoverable by the principal on learning the true facts[5].
Should an agent receive a secret commission or profit the principal may recover it as well as dismiss the agent[6].


Application to Real Estate
Let’s apply this to a real estate transaction, where agencies most commonly arise.
Perhaps you have heard of agents who desired to act for both a buyer and seller and to obtain commission from both. It is the duty of the agent to make full disclosure to both the buyer and seller of an intention to act for, and receive payment from, the other party. Both parties must be made fully aware of this intention and agree to the agent doing so[7]. In the event the agent does not tell both parties, or does not gain their consent, the commission will be lost.  These obligations apply in addition to any PAMDA or POA obligations.





[1] Garnac Grain Company Inc v HMF Faure & Fairclough Ltd
[2] Parker v McKenna
[3] Lintrose Nominees Pty Ltd v King
[4] Dargusch v Sherley Investments Pty Ltd
[5] Walden Properties Ltd v Beaver Properties Pty Ltd
[6] Fullwood v Hurley
[7] Fullwood v Hurley

Search This Blog